Children in Need makes me feel uncomfortable.
I once saw a protest from disabled people outside the BBC studios in protest against Children in Need years ago. They objected to Children in Need projecting them in a negative way, making people feel sorry for the children, and as a result, making the public stay with the image of the disabled as people to be pitied and unable to help themselves instead of showing them in a positive way.
I was told that the BBC has now changed how they report the Children in Need as a result. I wouldn’t know as I don’t watch it.
Another programme called Pride of Britain was on last week
http://www.prideofbritain.com
What annoyed me was the way it has portrayed the deaf in 2004 under the category Child of courage (text copied from the site and My input in BOLD)
I very much doubt this is Scott talking its a crap newspaper reporting style
—–
Inspirational teenager Scott is the only member of his family who can hear – and that means this schoolboy helps his profoundly deaf mum, dad and two brothers cope with their silent world.
Scott answers the phone, orders meals in restaurants and helps with trips to the post office, doctor and dentist.
Ok fair enough there are stupid people who insist on phoning you even though they know your deaf. The thing is, how do they know your phone number?? Did Scott’s parents hand out the number knowing they cant hear the phone? Can understand phone is for his use. Also banks can’t speak to Scott under the Data Protection act. Doctors sign a confidential act so they cant tell him about family problems
When his mum, who is also blind, wants to go shopping, Scott goes too. When his brothers want to order a burger, they come to him. And when his parents want to visit the bank, they turn to him.
I can’t speak for the blind, but ordering food these days is not a hard task. Like other BSL users they point to menu. Seems like they say they are not able to feed themselves without Scott. How did other deaf families cope? Mass starvation of deaf families? Government must investigate!!
Scott is the family’s lifeline, acting as ears to the outside world for his parents, Angela and Iain, and brothers Barry, 16, and Colin, seven, and using sign language to let them know what’s happening. The 14-year-old East Kilbride lad considers signing his first language rather than spoken English – and his dream is for it to be taught in schools just like French or German.
That’s great and I know for most deaf families sign language is their first language. But, sorry Scott, you may have a lifetime of campaigning as British Sign Language (BSL). BSL was recognised as an official British language by the UK government on 18th March 2003, but it does not have any legal protection. This means that Deaf people do not have full access to information and services that hearing people take for granted, including education, health and employment. (see right at the bottom)
He says,” Signing is so easy to pick up when you’re young and the difference it would make to the deaf would be incredible. I learned to sign soon after I was born, but I didn’t learn to speak until well after that. I didn’t speak until I was three or four.”
It’s a wonder Social Services haven’t persecuted his family maybe they thought he was deaf.
Last year, when he was just 13, Scott took his dad and older brother Barry to Canada to visit relatives, coping with the flights, lost luggage and a foreign country. But to Scott it was not particularly extraordinary.
“I just help my family communicate with hearing people,” he says. “I’ve been doing that since I was born, so to be honest, it’s nothing special to me. Even though I’ve had to grow up quite quickly and I have more responsibility, I still do everything other teenagers do. I’m not missing out on anything. I don’t really think about what I do. Helping with the shopping, answering the phone – it’s all really normal stuff to me.”
More responsibility?? Helping with the shopping? WTF? They are deaf they have arms and legs !
“People think it’s hard for me. But if you think my life is hard it’s a lot harder being a deaf child in a hearing family.”
Now this would be Scott talking here and he is correct. I am deaf person from a hearing family.
His proud Gran Elsie Reidy, 65, says, “the whole family is very independent but Scott has opened up new doors for them. He doesn’t allow them to live in a silent bubble.”
Assuming his Gran is not deaf and one of Scott’s parents is from a hearing family, I bet she doesn’t sign, another example deaf child in a hearing family.
“He enhances their life tremendously. He opens up the world to them. And he’s done it all without question.” The Judges opinion,
“Most lads his age would be out with their mates, but instead Scott’s at home looking after his family. No matter what he says, Scott is extraordinary.”
No he does it because he wanted to and judges thinks he stays in looking after the family, gosh they must think being deaf, they are not able to feed / wash and clothes them selves.
About BSL word below taken from another website
British Sign Language (BSL) is the first or preferred language of around 250,000 Deaf people in the UK. It is a language of space and movement using the hands, body, face and head. Around 120,000 hearing people also use BSL, meaning it is used more than Welsh or Gaelic.
Since the BDA started in 1890, we have been campaigning for Deaf people’s right to use BSL, to be educated in BSL, and to access information and services through BSL. We believe this is the best way for Deaf people to take part in society, equally to hearing people. That is why we campaigned for the government to recognise BSL.
BSL was recognised as an official British language by the UK government on 18 th March 2003, but it does not have any legal protection. This means that Deaf people do not have full access to information and services that hearing people take for granted, including education, health and employment.
The BDA wants BSL to be legalised, which will give BSL users the legal right to use it, bringing years of language discrimination to an end.